The paths of these two stars have intersected on several occasions due to their association with the luxury brand Bulgari
A series of well-publicised cases of "stalking" and of photographers following celebrities everywhere they went, led to the rushed introduction in 1997 of the Protection from Harassment Act.
It was thought that there would be about 200 cases a year but instead by 2002 there were more than 6,000. What had happened was that lawyers saw that there were ways of using the law that the government has not intended. For example, some lawyers have used it in workplace bullying claims or even to stop alleged anxiety or distress caused by neighbours or even relatives. But, worryingly for free speech, the law has also been used as a replacement for libel claims, particularly where the person making the claim is not so much interested in libel damages —increasingly hard to obtain —but more in suppressing what the person or publication wants to say about them.
Getting a quick harassment order by claiming that what a newspaper is publishing is causing the subject of the articles "alarm and/or distress" tends to shut up the offending publication. The cost of legal proceedings to have the harassment order lifted could then deter the publication from going ahead. A top union official used the harassment route to limit personal attacks on him by the London Evening Standard. A woman brought a claim against The Sun for publishing articles about her, which reported that three police officers had been demoted as a result of a complaint she had made about their alleged racist remarks.
But the most alarming use of the harassment law has been by a big energy company, RWE npower which runs a power station at Didcot in Oxfordshire. The company plans to empty Thrupp Lake, a local swimming, fishing and picnic spot, then line it with clay. It will then dump 60,000 tonnes of "fly ash", a by-product of burning coal that contains lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium. It then plans to wait for several years until the ash solidifies before attempting "remediation". As might be expected, the local residents have been up in arms against the plan and have been marching, demonstrating and photographing the early stages of the power company’s work —the cutting down of trees and the destruction of wildlife habitats.
The company hired security guards to keep the protesters at bay. The guards are an intimidating bunch, some of whom wear black face masks. But the company’s lawyers also went to the courts and used the harassment law to obtain injunctions stopping the protesters from harassing the guards. It said that demonstrating against them, photographing them and arguing with them was causing them "alarm and distress". Now the protesters can no longer photograph the guards, "loiter within five yards" of them "whether on foot or in vehicles" or speak threateningly to them.
All this sounds so ludicrous that you may wonder why the protesters have just ignored it. The answer is that if someone did, then he or she can be deemed to have broken the injunction, a criminal offence carrying a penalty of up to five years’ imprisonment. Thus a law intended to prevent people from being intimidated has had the opposite and unexpected result of intimidating people itself. Worse, it is in danger of suppressing all protest, no matter how legitimate and justified.
One of the leading company of lawyers in the harassment injunction scene advertises itself as "the market leader in obtaining ground-breaking injunctions on behalf of individuals and corporations who have been the subject of harassment by direct action protest groups." And how is this for the clincher? The injunction applies not only to the local protesters, but to anyone who has knowledge of it. So it is quite likely that if I were to travel up to Thrupp Lake, seek out one of the security guards and take him to task for endangering Britain’s freedom of expression, I could risk five years behind bars. Frightening, isn’t it?
Phillip Knightley is a veteran British journalist based in London
The paths of these two stars have intersected on several occasions due to their association with the luxury brand Bulgari
The students' demands range from a ceasefire in Israel's war with Hamas to calls for universities to stop investing in Israeli enterprises
Despite Kohli's flowing form ahead of the T20 World Cup in June, pundits have raised concerns over his strike-rate
Saudi Arabia has begun to explore extracting lithium from sea water
Speaking after meeting Lebanese leaders, French foreign minister says there had been "a lot of progress" over the French proposals
The three-shot winner from Japan says he is aiming to become a member of the PGA Tour in the future
Big-hitting Nienaber falters at the finish to settle for secondwhile former Abu Dhabi resident David Horsey takes the third spot at Saadiyat Beach Golf Club
The UAE is India's second-largest export destination after the US