Time to rewrite and ratify a new deal

As a long-time observer of American politics, I know that United States senators will decide whether to ratify New START, the arms control treaty with Russia negotiated this year, on the basis of a thorough evaluation of their country’s national interests.

By Radoslaw Sikorski (Disarmament)

  • Follow us on
  • google-news
  • whatsapp
  • telegram

Published: Sat 20 Nov 2010, 10:19 PM

Last updated: Thu 2 Apr 2015, 10:29 AM

As the democratically elected representatives of the American people, they alone can determine what those interests are.

The US remains the world’s most powerful state, however, and the senators’ decision will inevitably have an impact beyond their country’s borders. It will be particularly significant for Poland, a staunch ally of the US in NATO. So it is important to make clear: my government supports the ratification of New START, because we believe it will bolster our country’s security, and that of Europe as a whole.

President Barack Obama’s nuclear-disarmament efforts have gained wide support in Poland. The country’s first democratic prime minister, along with two former presidents, including Lech Waêsa, the legendary leader of Solidarity, published a joint article last year in support of Obama’s bold disarmament agenda.

For almost a year now, since the expiration of the original START treaty in December 2009, no US inspectors have been on the ground in Russia to verify the state of its nuclear arsenal. The START verification provisions provide crucial information that is essential for the force-planning process.

Without a treaty in place, holes will soon appear in the nuclear umbrella that the US provides to Poland and other allies under Article 5 of the Washington Treaty, the collective security guarantee for NATO members. Moreover, New START is a necessary stepping-stone to future negotiations with Russia about reductions in tactical nuclear arsenals, and a prerequisite for the successful revival of the Treaty on Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE).

While we in Poland do not perceive an immediate military threat from Russia, most of the world’s active tactical or sub-strategic nuclear weapons today seem to be deployed just east of Poland’s borders, in speculative preparation for conflict in Europe. The cataclysmic potential of such a conflict makes it essential to limit and eventually eliminate this leftover from the Cold War.

This was the reasoning behind the Polish-Norwegian initiative aimed at addressing the issue of tactical nuclear weapons within the larger arms-control framework that was launched in this past April. In effect, New START is the sine qua non for effective US leadership on the arms-control and non-proliferation issues that matter to Europe – from reviving the CFE treaty to preventing Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons.

More broadly, New START will cement the new, more positive tone in relations between Russia and the West. Indeed, we in Poland have adopted our own way of reconciliation with Russia, one based on dialogue and reciprocity.

As a result, Polish-Russian relations have improved significantly over the last three years – no easy feat, given the burden of our shared history. Though difficulties still lie ahead, Poland is determined to build a relationship with Russia based on mutual respect.

Also in the cards is more substantive cooperation between NATO and Russia in the field of missile defense, an issue discussed at this year’s NATO-Russia Summit in Lisbon, and that has the potential to transform NATO-Russia relations. In order for that to happen, Russia’s leaders must come to view missile defense as an opportunity to work together to address common threats, rather than a threat in itself.

Ratification of New START will increase mutual trust and show that the West and Russia, despite our disagreements, can work together on issues critical to our common security. Any delay to the treaty, however, will embolden those in Moscow who would rather have the West as an enemy than as a partner – and who thus would like to see the tenuous progress made in recent months to be undone.

Meanwhile, the Obama administration continues to pursue its plans for European missile defense. More than a year ago, Poland decided to take part in the new Phased Adaptive Approach, which will primarily protect America’s European allies. The Polish government has agreed to host elements of the modified European Missile Defense System on Polish territory in the second half of the decade.

I hope that US senators take into account the view from Warsaw in making their decisions. New START is in the interest of disarmament and of Europe. Poland supports ratification of this vitally important treaty.

Radosaw Sikorski is Poland’s Foreign Minister© Project Syndicate

More news from