Confronting the Taboo of Human Trafficking

Our television production team entered the three room apartment in Manama, Bahrain with plans to see an empty shelter for the victims of labor abuse. What we found was quite different and heart wrenching. Forty-year-old Suryavathi Rao fled the home of her employer that morning shoeless with only a nightgown and bible to her name.

By John Defterios

  • Follow us on
  • google-news
  • whatsapp
  • telegram

Published: Fri 13 Mar 2009, 9:42 PM

Last updated: Mon 6 Apr 2015, 1:08 AM

The years of domestic labour have taken their toll. She could easily pass for 60 if not a few years older. After working 16 hours a day, seven days a week for a year and a half, Suryavathi could not take it anymore.

She said through a translator that her meagre salary of $108 a month had not been paid for six months. She complained about not being fed meals and surviving on the generosity of her neighbour another domestic worker who pulled together leftovers to get by.

Suryavathi could not get through three sentences without breaking into tears. As a result of her fleeing for protection, she has become a runaway worker with no rights. Her employer holds her passport. The best she can hope for is to get the passport back and hope that the shelter can give her enough money to buy a ticket and fly home to Southern India. It is not that simple of course, since back home Suryavathi fears she won’t be welcomed back due to her “failure” to send back money and keep a job.

This is the life of a forced labourer and the complex world of human trafficking. Technically, Suryavathi was not trafficked. She had a sponsor agency that she paid $1100 to back in India and is still charging here 5 per cent a month interest on the balance. But she certainly did not expect slave like conditions when she arrived.

It is hard to think of a worst crime than the trafficking of humans. I was introduced to the cause by the First Lady of Egypt Suzanne Mubarak three years ago who heard of cases of child kidnapping, the trading of human organs and the sex trade involving teenage women.

In an exclusive interview this week in Bahrain, the First Lady explained that the more she learned, the more involved she became, “Whether it is regarded as a country of origin, transit or destination, it exists in all societies. Personally I came to realise what an insidious crime this was and how it was just really built on profit and on not only low morals, but no morals at all.”

Human trafficking and forced labour are big business. According to the United Nations International Labour Organisation (ILO) 12.3 million people are a product of forced labour. Of that total, more than 2.4 million have been trafficked across borders. Total profits from this illicit trade add up to $36 billion a year according to the UN, ranking third behind the illegal drugs and arms trade. In large part as a result of the End Human Trafficking Now campaign of Ms Mubarak the last few years, more than 150 countries have signed onto protocols to combat the crime. Legislation has been passed; the next big hurdle according to the First Lady is enforcement.

“Oh definitely we have a long, long way to go yet, because the traffickers are not caught. This is an organised crime that is working you know, underground”. When reminded that for every 800 people trafficked only one is prosecuted, she admits, “We still need to amend our laws; we need to draft new anti-trafficking laws.”

Having chaired two panels at this week’s “Human Trafficking at the Crossroads” conference in Manama, the other stark reality is the challenge of changing not only the laws on the books, but the mindset of the people who exploit innocent victims, either those who employ them or the middlemen who trade them.

In the Gulf, the biggest problem according to labour officials is the treatment of domestic and construction workers. 250,000 have officially reported cases of abuse according to UN officials.

The fact that Bahrain hosted this conference speaks volumes of getting the subject off the taboo list. Government officials want to open up to discuss why things need to change. A year ago, the Crown Prince of Bahrain Shaikh Salman Bin Hamad Bin Isa Al-Khalifa created the Labour Market Regulatory Authority (LMRA) to consolidate a handful of ministries, get every migrant worker registered and give them the freedom to move from one employer to another if ill treated. The effort, structure and technology are impressive – Bahraini officials admit the growing pains are daunting.

“It makes me very uncomfortable,” said the US-educated Crown Prince during an interview last summer, “And what I think is the greatest protection for workers is the elimination of the sponsorship system. Sponsorship in this region is similar to servitude in the United States 400 years ago.”

What is promising is that people at the very top and bottom of the “supply chain” of human trafficking are out fighting the cause. Ms. Mubarak has targeted top business leaders to sign on the dotted line to insure that no one in their operations or within their supplier community are employing trafficked labourers. 12,000 companies have signed on in three short years.

The First Lady’s strategy was to make inroads as quick as possible. “Rather than repeating what has been done, that we should start working from the top, working with the business community, who have the resources, who have the expertise, who have the technical capabilities of helping us to do something about this scourge of human trafficking.”

There is a concern that during this global downturn the treatment of workers will become less of a priority. Right now, companies are concerned about delivering profits, but hopefully doing the “right thing” does not fall by the wayside.

In the trenches you find real heroes providing advice, food and shelter to the victims.

The Migrant Workers Protection Society in Bahrain is under-funded and under-staffed, but three women of Indian origin have served as pillars of the operation have looked after 380 people who were desperate for help. It seems they don’t have enough fingers to plug all the leaks or loopholes while the system gets built in Bahrain.

Meanwhile, more than 200 participants at conference are looking for new strategies like a global phone hotline to make sure victims do not fall through the cracks. They are also trying to coordinate legislation and police investigations to put more perpetrators behind bars.

It is no small challenge when governments are working against organised crime rings, which are not only making big money, but to date have paid a very small price for their actions.

More news from